Sugata Bhattacharya stated that he was sitting on 8A in the first row of business class, next to accused Shankar Mishra, who was on 8C seat. He told that the victim woman was quite decent. Two junior air hostesses cleaned them. I went to one of his seniors and asked him to give a new seat for the old woman, but he flatly refused. However, she said that she could not do so, as she had to take permission from the captain. Bhattacharya said that the only option for him was to go to first class. Because, all the seats in the business class were full. The flight crew cleaned the seats and put blankets on the seats that smelled of urine.